Saturday, 11 December 2010

WWC♯D? No.2

WHAT WOULD CECIL SHARP DO? No2

Here is a video clip from Mayday 2010. It was filmed at Padstow in Cornwall, a uniquely Celtic corner of England. The “Old” or “Red Ribbon” Hobby Horse (or “Obby Oss” as they call it in Padstow) is one of three horses which come out into the town on Mayday. First to emerge in the morning is the Children’s Oss. The second is the Blue or “Peace” Oss, and the third is the Old Oss.

In this clip the Oss comes out of the Golden Lion pub and starts the day’s dancing. The dance will take all day, and will process throughout the whole town of Padstow. Traditionally it is good luck to be barged by the Oss’s tarred skirts, and in this clip we see it actually seize a young woman. The Oss is usually accompanied by one or more “Teasers”, who dance before it carrying something that looks like a decorated bat or clapper.


Mayday is Padstow’s “Day”, the day when it does it’s own thing. But something nags at the back of my mind when I watch these clips. There was a big revival in interest in English traditions in the 1970s, and Padstow was a big draw for enthusiasts who wanted to see, and to participate in, something utterly unique in the world. The B&Bs and hotels became booked up for miles around. I met at least one Londoner who was a regular down in Padstow – he would go there, put on his white clothes and red necker, and dance along with the Old Oss – and he wasn’t alone. I heard (second hand, so if you quote me don’t quote me as Gospel), that as the B&Bs filled up, more and more Padstonians  booked holidays in Ibiza. Cornwall depends on tourism for much of its wealth, but nonetheless calls tourists by the disparaging name of “grockles”. Padstow would empty out its natives and become a town where outsiders performed the tradition.

So when I look at the clips, I wonder how many people I am watching, either as onlookers or participants, are actually Cornishmen and Cornishwomen from Padstow. Maybe things have quieted down. Maybe they have reclaimed their Day as their own, to some extent. Maybe what I was told was complete eyewash anyway.

But it all made me wonder this: Is an ethnomusicologist free to become an enthusiast, a participant, a revivalist?

Ethnomusicology and looking at folk traditions strikes me as being a little like particle physics. When a traditional display is observed it is, like the behaviour of a particle, somehow changed. This can’t be helped. It is a mater of context. To an extent, if only to a small extent, the display is for the observer, whose presence slightly alters the context of the display. When the observer becomes a participant, the context changes further.

This is the point at which one usually takes a moral stance and states a principle, draws a line at the place beyond which one promises not to “interfere”. But “interfering” and not interfering both have consequences, as surely as effect follows cause. Recognising this, and placing traditions within changing times (which is surely where they are anyway!) is part and parcel of being able to see people’s music and traditions in context.

A couple of words which keep cropping up in my dippings-into ethnomusicology are “etic” and “emic”. To me they are a couple of suffixes. Basically their purpose is to differentiate between outside and inside a culture. Neither viewpoint is complete in itself. Insiders can be subjective to an extent that outsiders often can’t. Outsiders can be objective to an extent that insiders sometimes can’t.

I have been told that I have a good appreciation of “context”, particularly historical context. I don’t know. Do I? I do know that I certainly ought to if I am going to maintain an interest in subjects like this.

Okay, I asked: “Is an ethnomusicologist free to become an enthusiast, a participant, a revivalist?” Well, why not? Who could resist the chance to dance through the streets of Padstow, or to play in a gamelan ensemble, or to join in a Sardana in the town square in Girona? Go for it, but keep a sense of what it is you are doing.

_______________________   

I noticed that the second clip had appeared on the web site of the BNP (British National Party), who are reckoned to be a Fascist organisation. That's an interesting phenomenon in itself, the appropriation of the images of a traditional event for right-wing political purposes.

Tuesday, 7 December 2010

Diary of a glass-half-empty person 23


As I reclined on my chaise longue yestere’en, my Cheyenne rug tucked snuggly round my legs (probably my best feature, by the way) and a warming glass of Highland malt in my hand, I made the following cheerful remark.

“I love the way that street lights reflect off the snow, and make the townscape almost as bright as day!” I thought there might be a poem somewhere in this.

Consuela (my Tejana maid) paused in her dusting, drew in a breath, and replied thus:

“We’re in a teepee on top of the Sidlaws. We’re five miles from the nearest lit streets. We’re three miles walk from the nearest road, and the only reason we can get through to that is because I cleared a narrow path through the snow. Not with a proper snow-scoop either – you wouldn’t buy one the last time we were in B&Q, you said it was an extravagance and that we didn’t get deep enough snow in Scotland – but with your crumb-tray.”

She was referring to my antique silver crumb-tray (hallmarked Birmingham 1886), but still I felt her remark was a little tart and her general demeanour a trifle crabbit to boot. It put quite a damper on the rest of the evening, and in truth I got up today in a foul mood. It has lasted all day. Whilst waiting for my bus I was approached by a harmless little woman who asked me if the bus had been.

“I wouldn’t know,” I snapped. “I’m only standing here because I stopped to admire the view and now I’m frozen to the bloody bus stop.”

She shrank from me and walked off to thumb a ride.

I had already given Consuela a reciprocal mouthful by this time. She had risen sunnily, and had even been cheerful while spending forty-five minutes scouring the house for her Blackberry. When she eventually put her hand to it, she raised it triumphantly aloft.

“It’s always in the last place you look!” she cried.

“Of course it is, you numpty,” I said. “Why the hell would you look anywhere else once you had found it?”

To cap it all the news regarding our lurker is not looking good. His advocate has applied for a writ of Feasance Buccleuch to mature in a sennight. Our only hope is that the Isbister Fiscal can rule it over-wrought. Hmmm.

I promise to be more gruntled tomorrow.

Friday, 3 December 2010

Happy Birthday, in advance, Dave Brubek

Dave will be 90 on Monday. Here is his tribute to Chopin, but I think in places it is as much a tribute to Errol Garner.

Go YouTube.

Tuesday, 30 November 2010

Marie's Jukebox, 2


I promise I’ll get back to my political (and humorous) stuff in due course. Meanwhile here’s my next batch of Jukebox hits…

  1. Dean Martin – Sway
  2. UNO Choir – Anchored in the Lord
  3. Yuksek – Tonight (Radio Edit)
  4. Steve Cropper – Land of 1000 Dances
  5. The Cambridge Singers – The Sailor & Young Nancy, E J Moeran
  6. Groove Armada – Healing
  7. Jr Walker – Shotgun
  8. Kraftwerk – Aero Dynamik (Kling Klang Dynamix)
  9. Cliff Richard – Quizas, Quizas, Quizas
  10. LPO – Requiem Aeternam, W A Mozart
  11. Leonard Cohen – In My Secret Life
  12. Chet Baker – Time After Time
  13. Rosanne Cash – God is in the Roses
  14. Michael Flanders & Donald Swann – Song of the Weather
  15. Blondie – Hanging on the Telephone
  16. Funkadelic – One Nation Under a Groove
  17. Jackie Wilson – Higher and Higher
  18. Slim Gaillard & Slam Stewart – Opera in Vout
  19. Mandroid – Subsonic Tendencies


Just looking at the stuff that has come up on this shuffle, only one track is later than 2004. Must get myself up-time.

Friday, 26 November 2010

Marie's Jukebox, 1


I have decided that when I am in the mood for music I will set my player to shuffle and see what comes on. And then I thought why not share it with you. So here is my first jukebox playlist. I’m sticking to twenty tracks each time I post this. See if there is anything you don’t recognize from this list and go looking for it (iTunes, YouTube, wherever), or if there is a memory-jogger for you.


  1. Noel Harrison – Windmills Of Your Mind
  2. Simon Mayor – Jig, from St Paul’s Suite, Gustav Holst; arranged for mandolin.
  3. Charles Trenet – Douce France
  4. PIL – Public Image
  5. Edwin Starr – War
  6. Richard Lumsden – Spinners Loop, from “Morris, A Life with Bells On”.
  7. Santana – Jugando
  8. The Beatles – In My Life
  9. Bob Marley – Jamming
  10. Covenant – We Stand Alone (live)
  11. Devon Irons – Vampire
  12. Capercaillie – Soraidh Bhuam Gu Barraidh
  13. Los Lobos – Amselma
  14. Aerosmith & Run DMC – Walk This Way
  15. Dick Dale – Front Porch Blues
  16. Flogging Molly – The Worst Day Since Yesterday
  17. Nathan Abshire – Pine Grove Blues (Ma Negresse)
  18. Academy of Ancient Music, Catherine Bott & Christopher Hogwood – When I Am Laid In Earth, from “Dido and Aeneas”, Henry Purcell.
  19. Ian Dury & The Blockheads – Sex and Drugs and Rock and Roll
  20. The Miracles – You Really Got A Hold On Me

Purcell

Thursday, 25 November 2010

Where's Custer?



Yesterday Consuela (my Tejana maid) pointed to the blanket under which I was snuggling on my chaise longue. You may remember it. It depicts an incident after the Battle of the Little Big Horn in which Custer, having been captured alive, was bludgeoned to death by an old Cheyenne woman wielding an iron skillet.

“How can you be sure that’s what happened?” she asked.

I can’t, of course, but on the other hand Native American accounts of historical events are at last being listened to, particularly as they are seen to agree with modern battlefield archaeology.

The mythical, European-American stories, the so-called history of “Custer’s Last Stand”, or the “Battle of the Little Big Horn”, are falling down all around us. The Hollywood Custer – the image of Errol Flynn, sabre in hand, doggedly defending the cavalry flag and the last man to fall, even Arthur Penn’s gibbering, delusional figure from Little Big Man – is beginning to fray. Even the name of the event is under question. The “Last Stand”, always a one-sided concept, has not seemed credible for some time. Now the term “Battle” looks shaky. The event, in Lakota and Cheyenne records, doesn’t seem to be important, not as important as, say, the Battle of Rosebud Creek even though that battle was not decisive, not as important as the domestic affairs of the ad hoc confederation of tribes. When you consider that it amounted to a foolish incursion by less than two hundred soldiers (the approximate size of Custer’s detachment once troops under Reno and Benteen had separated from them) towards a sizeable native encampment, and that the defenders dealt with the incursion in “as long as it takes a hungry man to eat his dinner” (according to a Native American description) it is hardly surprising that the event is not given much prominence.

The famed 7th Cavalry were not the elite of the army. The minimum recruiting age was 21, but many recruits were much younger – presumably either they lied about their age or a blind eye was turned. The amount of time spent on horseback brought about damage to the troopers’ spines which must have been permanently agonizing. Skulls found at the scene of the fighting had bad teeth, presumably from army diet. Life in the 7th Cavalry, stationed in remote forts must have been dreadful. There is no record, as far as I know, of the names of the troopers who rode with and died with Custer. The only positive identification from the battlefield was made by reference to the dimensions of a skull, an image of which was superimposed upon a photograph of a renowned scout, Mitch Bouyer. Bouyer was the son of a French Canadian man and a Santee Lakota woman, and was one of the most expert scouts ever to work for the cavalry. To my mind even Custer himself was not definitely identified, although the spot where he is supposed to have been found is marked.

Having poked a stick into a hornets’ nest, Custer’s contingent of cavalry had taken up the best defensive positions it could on three linked rises. Initially the dismounted troopers on each position formed skirmish lines, each man a few metres away from the next, and fired down with their standard single-shot rifles. These rifles would have had the advantage at first, having a greater range than the arms carried by their enemies. The attackers were not armed with bows and tomahawks but with a variety of repeating firearms, which meant that when they got within range, by moving from cover to cover while the troopers were reloading, they had vastly superior firepower. The skirmish lines broke and the herding instinct took over – the troopers huddled together, becoming in fact an easier target, and only a handful could have made it to the next piece of high ground as theirs was overrun. Eventually a number of troopers ran from the last position towards a ravine, either as a diversionary tactic or in a panic retreat. The last high spot having been over-run, these fleeing soldiers were cut down before they reached the ravine. It was there that Mitch Bouyer’s remains were found.

Mitch Bouyer, posing for the camera!

All the cavalrymen’s and scouts’ bodies were mutilated, a typical post-mortem punishment amongst some Plains peoples designed to curse their enemies’ time in the after-life. It is said that Custer’s body was found, naked but relatively untouched, and speculation ran that the Lakota and Cheyenne warriors left him unmutilated out of respect for a brave commander. However I don’t buy that for several reasons. Firstly there is no proof that they could have recognized him. Secondly he had no reputation amongst the Lakota and Cheyenne, having not been engaged in any significant actions against them. Thirdly, he was probably not the only officer in the contingent to be wearing buckskins. The nakedness I can credit, as the buckskins would have been worth taking away. I honestly doubt that there would have been a single unmutilated body; I think that Custer’s body wasn’t “found” any more than anyone else’s, it was simply that it was expedient for the myth if the place where he fell could be “identified” for the purpose of putting up a marker, and it had to be on the last height to be overrun.

There were no white observers of the scene. The only accounts of the action are those of native witnesses, and as I said the event was probably seen as no big deal by them. These days experts give most credence to the claim that a warrior by the name of White Cow Bull killed Custer. But then, what of the story of the enraged Cheyenne woman? I like that story, but if there were no cavalry survivors it falls; if Custer was unknown to the Lakota and Cheyenne, it falls.

Why is this all so important to me? It is important because it draws attention to the fact that European minds, so immersed in the tradition of documented “fact”, have found it not only difficult to accept oral, handed-down histories, but actually easy to dismiss them. This assumption of superiority has dogged our consideration of history. Granted things can change in oral history – its greatest drawback is that it can be corrupted by “Chinese Whispers” – but it is never the product of an inferior; it is always another window upon historical truth, and a valid window too from which we can gaze out at a different perspective to the one we are used to. Meanwhile, the Western way of considering history is not in itself perfect; facts are lost, historical records are lost, those that remain are subject to individual interpretation, history is seen through a cultural filter. On the 8th of October this year, British historian David Starkey (speaking on BBC Radio's "Any Questions" programme) said words to the effect that History should be based solely on facts. Good luck with that.

Saturday, 20 November 2010

No Borders, No Bosses. Part 2.


I pledge allegiance to no flag and to no country but, as a citizen of the world, to common humanity and to the liberty which is the right and heritage of all.

No Borders:

If I were to make a pledge, then it would be something like the words above. But having made it once, I could not repeat it every day. If I did, it would have become a creed and an institution, I would be shackled to it in the dead letter, I would cease to live in the spirit of it – and I want to live in the spirit of it.

The smallest functioning, autonomous, political unit current in the world is the nation-state. Forget the States of the USA, the Cantons of Switzerland, the Départements of France, the Local Authorities of Great Britain; disregard all the districts, oblasts, townships, “communes”, wards, and parishes worldwide – like it or not, the nation-state is the entity below which political powers will not divide themselves. National power is the ambition of democratic political parties and autocrats alike. Even separatists who campaign for independence for their ethnic or cultural enclave have an eye to making it into a nation-state and to “taking their place” with other nations. When the Soviet Union was dissolved, each former member declared itself a sovereign state, and the race for internal power was furious. When Yugoslavia began to tear itself apart, each constituent "republic" declared itself an ethnocentric nation-state. When the IRA waged a terrorist campaign against the United Kingdom it was with a view to including Ulster in the nation-state of the Republic of Ireland. The only solution proposed in the middle east, short of one side annihilating the other, is in terms of recognising national status for each side. Nation-states may be as small as Monaco or Liechtenstein, or as populous as the People’s Republic of China, or as vast as Russia, but the principle does not seem to vary – the nation-state is the lowest unit of ambition to the professional political class.

Notwithstanding devolution, notwithstanding the supposed “checks and balances” and States’ rights of the US system, the national assemblies in Cardiff and Edinburgh in the United Kingdom, to give two examples, the drive to dominate a nation-state is there in every political organization.

Neither is there any coherent drive towards effective international federacy, co-operation, or super-statism. The looseness of the United Nations, with the power of veto given to the handful of nation-states with the most perceived status (or sometimes muscle), means that many other nation-states routinely defy it. Israel does continuously, without serious opposition; Ba’athist Iraq did so, mainly as a sheer but unsuccessful bluff, until invaded by the armies of other nation-states acting with only dubious and contentious reference to the UN’s rulings; other nation-states – usually little ones with no oil and no strategic importance – have done so without any significant disturbance. The lawgiving centralism of the European Community constantly brings it into conflict with the national interest and sovereignty of constituent nation-states. The Commonwealth is now of little significance beyond sporting ties.

The nation-state is possessive, fearful, bellicose, jealous, vainglorious, selfish, and assured of its supposed superiority over its neighbours. It embodies character traits that one would discourage in one’s child or one’s sister. The nation-state sends it young men and women to war, and does so behind its national icons and idols, against the young men and women of another nation-state.

The nation-state often claims to be the protector of the individual rights and freedoms of its citizens. In fact the nation-state subsumes those rights and freedoms, demands allegiance, demands quiescence, fosters a level of national sentiment (or rather national sentimentality). Even in nation-states pretending democracy the sum of the citizen’s participation is to sign his or her autonomy away by marking an X on a piece of paper once every four or five years, and gifting all decision-making to the professional political class.
H L Menken

“But surely,” says the political class (the same political class that routinely praises the intelligence of the electorate in being able to make up its minds who to vote for!), “the average person in the street does not have the necessary skills to govern himself? Let us take on the awful burden of making decisions for him, thereby liberating him from care.” And in so saying, and so doing, the political class goes on to prove the cynical quip of H L Menken – “Democracy is the theory that the common people know what they want and deserve to get it good and hard.” It is the theory that there is a majority of wise men over fools, or rather the pretence, because it is in the interests of the political class that the rest of us can be fooled into voting for them and into perpetuating the system where they can not only aspire to political power but can achieve and maintain it. When Abraham Lincoln said, “You may fool all the people some of the time, you can even fool some of the people all of the time, but you cannot fool all of the people all of the time”, he neglected the fact that all a politician has to do is to fool enough of the people enough of the time. At least within bourgeois democracy that is enough!
Abraham Lincoln

But I would say that even the most foolish citizen has some recognisable and reliable level of knowledge about what concerns him or her most closely. The more remote the decision-making has to be by dint of the smallest functioning, autonomous, political unit’s being the nation-state, then the more that the citizen can be excluded by the political class from the process of decision-making. It is so easy for that citizen to become convinced by the argument that he or she hasn’t the necessary skills to govern himself or herself, so easy to persuade each citizen simply to be quiescent, to watch the pretty images on TV and drink the cheap lager from the supermarket, so easy to become complacent and apathetic. Panem et circenses!

So what to put in the place of the nation-state, and who has the right to change things? It seems to me that asking the ordinary citizen to become more directly involved in grass-roots, ground-up, non-party-dominated politics is a way of educating the ordinary citizen towards the skills which the political class insists we don’t have. So let us look for the smallest communal unit that we can find, whether it be a village, a factory, or whatever – what it is will depend on circumstances – and make that our smallest functioning, autonomous, political unit, without need for any larger unit. Let those units exist not to compete, but to co-operate with each other1, to obey the evolutionary principle of mutual aid, recognizing as they do that that mutuality can’t be limited by the traditional borders of nation-states, that pressures and priorities may be exactly the same in Coldstream and Cornhill-on-Tweed, or in Les Moëres and Houtem, or in Coutts and Sweetgrass. The answer is go small! The right to do this rests with the ordinary citizen, whom the political class has effectively disenfranchised whilst leaving the illusion that his or her X actually means something more than the perpetuation of that class’s hold on political power.

In Britain today we have a situation where electoral participation in general election voting is still 20% lower than its post-WW2 peak, and at 65% is not a great deal higher than its trough of 60% in 2001. Also notwithstanding the unpopularity of the immediately previous administration (New Labour), the most readily-electable alternative (the Conservative Party) failed to gain an overall majority and had to form a coalition with the third-place party (Liberal Democrat). This coalition has embarked on a programme of cuts to state spending coupled with consumer tax rises (VAT will rise from 17.5% to 20% in the New Year), meanwhile favouring big business with a cut in Corporation Tax to a record low level2. There is a lot of public disquiet and dissent both low key and more recently high key with street protests by students about probable rises in the cost of university education. Now my purpose here is not to argue the rights and wrongs of the various actions of the parties of the political class, nor the rights or wrongs of any particular street protests.

The ideal is to break the hold of this system. It cannot be done by asking the perpetuators of the system to reform it. They will never reform it because they will never reform themselves, will never cut away from themselves the very thing that enables them to maintain power. They as a class are not afraid of the people they govern. It can only be done from down here, by exercising democracy at the smallest practicable level. I can suggest two things. The first is to get involved in any existing, democratically-run (or potentially democratically-run) body outside of government. For example a trade union. You may have to take on the power-structure within that body, but you can do so by working to increase grass-roots participation in that body. The second is to abstain from the voting process for the national parliament or congress. Now, it has been put to me that withholding one’s vote in a national election merely hands political power to one or the other of a couple of parties. Whilst I can see that argument, I would say that there is a level of electoral participation below which even a “victorious” party has to acknowledge that the nation is ungovernable under their system.

Combining these two actions ought, I feel, to bring about a new way of doing things out of necessity. A participatory democracy working from the ground up, similar to the late Murray Bookchin’s “Libertarian Municipalism”, ought to evolve.

Emma Goldman
 There is a big caveat. It would be necessary to move on from using existing organizations and bodies to forming new communities to run things. There will be no legal framework for doing so, it would be a direct challenge to the power structure that already exists. Those who clung on to power would declare it to be illegal and would fight it. As Emma Goldman said, “Every great idea is against the law.” This is where the hard work would come in, and to quote Thomas Jefferson, “We are not to expect to be translated from despotism to liberty in a feather-bed”. This is the point where dissent finds itself transformed to revolution (in all senses of the word) and in the face of reaction from the powers-that-be has three choices: surrender, passive resistance, or active resistance. Dissenters would have to choose, and it would be a difficult choice.
Thomas Jefferson

Let us suppose that it did become possible to have local, communitarian, ground-upward democracy; how would the autonomous communities interact? Of necessity and for the survival of all, it would have to be with mutuality and cooperation, each community helping its immediate neighbours. Also to an overwhelming extent it would have to be with disregard for pre-existing “national” boundaries, as the next-door-neighbour cooperation formed a network. Any decisions affecting more than one community would have to be the subject of specific conventions. These conventions would be set up for a specific purpose, would last as long as the issue was live, and would then be disbanded. They would not be set up to govern the communities but to serve their interests.

I know this sounds over-simple, but I am a blogger and this is only a blog. I would write a book, but for the fact that I am sure that what I am summarizing here has been already stated at length by others. You will be able to find something of this in many works by secular and religious communitarians, by revolutionary and pacifist anarchists, by political philosophers such as Bookchin and Alex Knight; there are hints and more than hints of it in the writings of such diverse people as Karl Marx and Thomas Jefferson, and even in the original concepts of the constitutions which formed the basis of (yes!) some nation-states. Read Kropotkin if you will, read Alexander Berkman if you will.

Instantly to your mind might questions about how important aspects of infrastructure might be handled. How would the railways run? How would the mail be delivered? How would hospitals function? How would justice be administered? Certainly having gone through the birth pangs of constructing a new society its citizens would have their work cut out for them – there would be no need to encourage democratic participation, because it would be an absolute necessity, a continuing experiment! It would be hard work from the word go. I certainly don’t have all the answers to hand, so for now let’s leave these questions to one side…

To be continued.


______________________________  

1  The familiar (and to my mind unthinking) objection from the Right will be that this simply isn’t in “human nature”, that we are by that nature competitive and not cooperative, according to the “survival of the fittest” rule in Darwinism. That is a view of almost unbelievable narrowness and naivety which comes from a misinterpretation of 19c philosopher Herbert Spencer’s phrase “survival of the fittest” to mean that only the toughest, fastest, strongest survive, taking “fit” to mean nothing more than a bodily condition. But if dog eats dog to survive, then the last two dogs will fight each other to the extinction of the canine race. The word “fittest” means “most suited”, and this can mean, and in fact should mean more often than it means the most ruggedly individualistic, the most communal, the most cooperative. Humankind is a societal species, a species that has often, in its neglected and unwritten histories (those which do not only record “Great Men”), has relied on mutual aid for its survival. It will need to rely on this again, and soon, and will need to muzzle the dog-eating dogs in its midst. I can recommend a book into which I have only dipped in the past. If you can find an English translation, then read Mutual Aid: a Factor of Evolution by Pyotr Alexeyevich Kropotkin from the introduction to which I quote:

“
Two aspects of animal life impressed me most during the journeys which I made in my youth in Eastern Siberia and Northern Manchuria. One of them was the extreme severity of the struggle for existence which most species of animals have to carry on against an inclement Nature; the enormous destruction of life which periodically results from natural agencies; and the consequent paucity of life over the vast territory which fell under my observation. And the other was, that even in those few spots where animal life teemed in abundance, I failed to find -- although I was eagerly looking for it -- that bitter struggle for the means of existence, among animals belonging to the same species, which was considered by most Darwinists (though not always by Darwin himself) as the dominant characteristic of struggle for life, and the main factor of evolution…

Wherever I saw animal life in abundance, as, for instance, on the lakes where scores of species and millions of individuals came together to rear their progeny; in the colonies of rodents; in the migrations of birds which took place at that time on a truly American scale along the Usuri; and especially in a migration of fallow-deer which I witnessed on the Amur, and during which scores of thousands of these intelligent animals came together from an immense territory, flying before the coming deep snow, in order to cross the Amur where it is narrowest -- in all these scenes of animal life which passed before my eyes, I saw Mutual Aid and Mutual Support carried on to an extent which made me suspect in it a feature of the greatest importance for the maintenance of life, the preservation of each species, and its further evolution.

And finally, I saw among the semi-wild cattle and horses in Transbaikalia, among the wild ruminants everywhere, the squirrels, and so on, that when animals have to struggle against scarcity of food, in consequence of one of the above-mentioned causes, the whole of that portion of the species which is affected by the calamity, comes out of the ordeal so much impoverished in vigour and health, that no progressive evolution of the species can be based upon such periods of keen competition.”

Consequently, when my attention was drawn, later on, to the relations between Darwinism and Sociology, I could agree with none of the works and pamphlets that had been written upon this important subject. They all endeavoured to prove that Man, owing to his higher intelligence and knowledge, may mitigate the harshness of the struggle for life between men; but they all recognized at the same time that the struggle for the means of existence, of every animal against all its congeners, and of every man against all other men, was ‘a law of Nature’. This view, however, I could not accept, because I was persuaded that to admit a pitiless inner war for life within each species, and to see in that war a condition of progress, was to admit something which not only had not yet been proved, but also lacked confirmation from direct observation.”
Pyotr Alexeyevich Kropotkin

2  To be fair, the lowest rate of 20% will be applied to the smallest limited companies.